Close your eyes and imagine taking a bite of the best chocolate chip cookie. It’s warm, crunchy on the outside, gooey as you get to the center, the perfect ratio of dough to chocolate and topped with flaky sea salt.

There’s nothing quite like it.

Ideally, the cookie is fresh out of the oven, which means it is approximately 17 degrees too hot to eat but that has never stopped anyone. You take a bite, immediately regret your decision, attempt to blow on the cookie while it is still in your mouth and spend the next week nursing the burned roof of your mouth. And yet, if someone puts a fresh cookie in front of you, you have to eat it immediately. Especially if there is a cold glass of milk involved.

A chocolate chip cookie is one of life’s simplest pleasures. It is a dessert requiring only the essentials: sugar, butter, flour, chocolate and, if the baker knows what they’re doing, enough salt to keep things interesting. It is also one of the few foods capable of transporting me directly back to elementary school, when someone’s mom would bring cookies into class for a birthday and suddenly 25 children were willing to behave for approximately four minutes.

In search of more of that childlike joy, I decided to search for the best chocolate chip cookie in the Gallatin Valley.

The rules are simple: try as many chocolate chip cookies as I can reasonably justify eating and rate each one on a scale of 1 to 10. I say “reasonably” because there is a limit to how many cookies one person can eat in the name of journalism. I have not yet discovered what that limit is.

I understand this mission is entirely subjective. There is no scientific formula for cookie excellence, despite my willingness to create one. My ideal cookie is thin, rich with dark chocolate, crisp around the edges, soft in the middle and finished with flaky sea salt. If you prefer a thick, cakey cookie with milk chocolate chips, we can still be friends. I just don’t want you judging my rankings.

To no one’s surprise, my favorite cookie comes from the James Beard Award-winning Wild Crumb. Their cookie is large and thin, with a crunchy exterior, softer center and generous layers of chocolate chunks. The salt-to-sugar ratio is, in my completely unbiased opinion, excellent.
Photo by Carli Johnson
It is also conveniently located, making it an easy mid-day pick-me-up. This is important because the best cookie is not necessarily the best cookie if I have to drive two hours to get it.

Another top contender is Little Star Diner’s milk and cookies dessert. It would have taken the number one spot if it weren’t a seasonal dessert. The cookies are baked fresh, ordered at the beginning of the meal and served hot with a cold glass of milk from Kalispell Creamery.

It is essentially childhood in a dessert course.

The cookies get all the ratios right, but more importantly, the presentation makes you feel like you have been handed an after-school snack by someone who loves you. And sometimes that is enough to make an adult forget they have emails to answer.
If you’re willing to venture out to Four Corners, Aurore Bakery offers a cookie on the opposite end of the spectrum. It is big, fluffy and covered in chocolate chunks, with a little salt on top. The texture is closer to cake than cookie, with an airy lightness that almost makes you not feel guilty when you eat the entire thing.

Aurore’s cookie reflects its French flair: elegant, soft and a little more refined than what I usually picture when I hear “chocolate chip cookie.”

While you’re out there, you might as well stop at The Coffee Pot Bakery Cafe. Its cookie is similar to Aurore’s but feels more distinctly American—smaller chocolate chips, a little more air and a “straight from grandma’s kitchen” quality.

Then there’s Cafe M, which has three locations throughout the valley and makes for an easy cookie pit stop. Its cookie most closely resembles the classic store-bought cookie of my childhood, which I mean as a compliment. If I were still in kindergarten, it would probably be number one.

Unfortunately, I have a sophisticated palate now. Or at least that’s what I’m telling myself as I eat cookies for research.

Studio Coffee Roasters near campus offers a solid cookie, although I’ve found its other pastries to be the real home runs, particularly the coffee cake muffins and vegan cupcakes.

And then there are the honorable mentions.

Uncle Dan’s Cookies in Big Sky is closed for the summer, but that doesn’t make it any less worthy of inclusion. The slope-side shack at the Madison Base at Big Sky Resort is a winter must-stop. Grab a cookie before getting on the chairlift and enjoy the sugar boost you’ll need to make it through the rest of the day.

If you’re visiting in the summer, you can still find their cookies at the Hungry Moose Market in Big Sky Town Center.

This search is far from over. There are more bakeries, coffee shops, different towns, and, presumably, cookies waiting to be judged.
In the interest of thoroughness—and absolutely nothing else—I intend to try them all.
Carli Johnson is a Bozeman-based writer and staff writer for Explore Big Sky. When she’s not writing, she’s finding inspiration along wild rivers and in the scenic backcountry, with something delicious from a local bakery in hand.
Read More

Stories From Yellowstone

Best of Yellowstone Country

Discover the best of Yellowstone Country, from Big Sky and Bozeman to Jackson Hole and Cody. Explore top restaurants, coffee shops, shopping, outdoor adventures, wildlife tours, and local attractions across Montana and Wyoming.
READ MORE

What's the Rush? What's Your Hurry?

A rushed Yellowstone trip gives way to a slower, more meaningful experience, where lingering in fewer places leads to unexpected wildlife moments and lasting memories.
READ MORE

Keeping Yellowstone's Wildlife on the Move

From elk and mule deer to grizzly bears, learn how scientists and conservationists are working to keep Yellowstone’s wildlife moving safely across the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem.
READ MORE

The "How" of Conservation

Inside the Property and Environment Research Center, this piece explores the “how” of conservation—using markets, policy, and partnerships with Yellowstone National Park to strengthen the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem.
READ MORE

ABOUT

GETTING HERE

OUR BLOG

GETTING HEREEXCLUSIVE OFFERSSTAYDINEACTIVITIESREAL ESTATESHOP LOCALEVENTSBLOGABOUTYELLOWSTONE MAP